Positive Deviance/Hearth

Positive Deviance/Hearth

Positive Deviance/Hearth (PDH) is a community-based and food-based approach with three interrelated goals: 

• To reduce the prevalence of malnutrition among children under five years. 
• To build local capacity to treat malnourished children and sustain the rehabilitation of children. 
• To prevent future malnutrition among all children in the community. 

In 2022, more than 21,000 at risk and underweight children under five years were enrolled into PDH programmes in nine countries, with 48.4% (n=9815) fully rehabilitated and graduated in three months. (Data from 9 of the 22 countries implementing PDH)

‘Positive deviance’ means straying from the norm, but in a beneficial way. Despite stark poverty and food scarcity, some caregivers find ways to raise well-nourished children. Understanding what these ‘positive deviant families’ are doing differently from the caregivers of malnourished children in the same community is key. This inquiry often identifies positive practices that are unique to that context, such as Vietnamese mothers collecting shrimp for their children while working in rice paddies, Ecuadorian women pre-masticating meat before giving it to their children, and mothers in Democratic Republic of Congo feeding their children dried and powdered caterpillars in their porridge. Families with malnourished children are then supported to adopt these positive practices through hands-on nutrition education and rehabilitation sessions conducted in the home (‘hearth’) of a community volunteer.  

Hearth is the 10 to 12 day rehabilitation and education session for underweight and moderately wasted children and their primary caregivers. Grandmothers and fathers are also involved during the Hearth sessions in many contexts. During hearth sessions, the children are fed nutritious meals as an extra meal, based on locally available, low-cost nutritious foods and positive deviant foods, which the caregivers prepare together using ingredients they contribute. The caregivers also listen to one key Hearth message per day, for a total of six messages that are local solutions identified in PD households that address the major challenges contributing to malnutrition in the community. PDH encourages behaviour change through practice by doing. As children respond to improved nutrition by gaining appetite, energy and weight, their families experience the value of the positive deviant practices first-hand. After the Hearth session, volunteers continue to monitor the children’s growth and support the families to apply the new behaviours they learned at home and help overcome any barriers.   

World Vision began utilising the Positive Deviance/Hearth (PDH+) approach in nutrition programming as early as 1999. Starting in Latin America, the organisation soon expanded the implementation of PDH to more than 40 countries in Asia, Africa, MEER, and Latin America. This approach is one of World Vision’s core project models in nutrition, and is currently being used in more than 20 countries. Since 2021, WV is now implementing PDH+. The ‘plus’ component includes additional prevention interventions integrated with PDH. These interventions can include, and are not limited to: Regular or decentralized Growth Monitoring and Promotion (GMP), IYCF counselling, mother support groups, nurturing care groups, biofortification, kitchen gardens, micronutrient powders, animal revolving funds, and savings groups. 

Cost of Programming

Costs for PDH integrated with food security include significant investment initially in training and start-up costs, and remain high as the activities are scaled up in each fiscal year. Cost analysis from area programmes in Bangladesh, Honduras, India and Mali show a per capita cost ranging from $0.73 in Mali to $4.86 in India and $9 in Bangladesh. Up to 80 per cent of the overall programme cost in India was for food production activities (animal and garden inputs).